If you're asking "Do card spirits really exist?", there's currently no reliable evidence to prove that every deck of tarot contains an independent spirit. However, the concept of "card spirits" does exist in different tarot communities and occult practices. Some understand it as the spiritual consciousness of the cards, others as "the personality of the deck, the relationship between the user and the cards," and still others see it purely from a psychological perspective as projection and intuitive patterns formed after familiarizing themselves with the deck. Therefore, I wouldn't directly tell students "every tarot deck has a card spirit." A more precise statement is: card spirits are a specific tarot belief and practice, not a core theory that must be accepted when learning tarot. #Tarot #TarotReading #TarotCourses #CardSpirit #MindSpirit